'Little comments, outright inappropriateness': Why minority military families may feel unwelcome off-base
A survey found widespread concern from Black, Latino, and Asian military families about inequality in cities where bases are located.
While the military has become more racially diverse, a recent survey found some Black and Hispanic service members don’t always feel welcome off base in their civilian host communities.
The Association of Defense Communities conducted the survey, asking service members and their families what they think about the towns and cities they call home, outside the gate.
“The conversation started with the murder of George Floyd, the unrest and protests over the summer,” Matt Borron, executive director at the Association of Defense Communities, said. The group connects military bases with their host communities.
Almost every Black military spouse who was surveyed reported unequal access to employment and said the criminal justice system is unfair.
“Increase the amount of minorit[ies] in higher positions of businesses, access to better education, access to non-racial healthcare and food.”
“It's not surprising that these communities reflect what's going on in society,” Borron said.
Some Black and Hispanic families say sometimes they don’t even feel safe off base. Borron said that can make or break a service member’s decision to stay in the military.
“They're making career decisions,” he said. “They'll leave the military rather than go to someplace where they don't feel safe.”
Some local civilian communities say they want to address the situation.
Karockas Watkins heads up a task force on diversity, equity and inclusion for the Huntsville/Madison Chamber of Commerce in northern Alabama, near Redstone Arsenal. Huntsville/Madison is one of several chambers across the country that encouraged their local military families to participate in the survey.
“Some of the findings are in line with what we see in the United States all over,” Watkins said. “We had several people who felt actually there were no issues of race here. And we had on the other hand some that feel like we need more education, and that justice is not being served.”
Watkins said the chamber plans to increase diversity through a mentoring program and grants for minority-owned businesses, as well as roundtable discussions to learn more about the needs of military families.
“A lot of times we assume we know what people want, what they need, and so we want to hear it from them,” Watkins said. “There may be things that we can do, maybe some things that we can’t do — but we need to listen to our community.”
Lawyer and entrepreneur Jennifer Brantley said the survey results are pretty much in line with her own experiences as a Black professional married to an Air Force chaplain. They've lived in Georgia, Nebraska, and are currently stationed overseas in a remote area of England.
“Little comments, microaggressions in the workplace, outright inappropriateness. As a minority, you feel like you just have to sit there and take it,” Brantley said. “Or if you say anything, you become the bad guy or the ‘angry Black woman’ trope.”
The lack of diversity she saw in military communities led her to develop FindMe Mobile, an app that connects Black and Hispanic military members with local businesses like hair salons and restaurants.
“And it's more than hair care for minorities,” Brantley said about the need for community connections. “We need something that makes us feel safe, where we know both our presence and our dollars will be welcome.”
“I would like to be a part of this community and my voice be heard because I’m very concern[ed] about my family’s safety due to housing issues with neighbors who don’t follow the rules and creat[e] a very toxic and hostile environment for me and my family.”
But she says the path to equity is more complicated than an app or roundtable chats.
“I think it's more about education versus talking to people and talking at people,” Brantley said. “Every effort is appreciated, but we need to figure out: What can we do to get to actual change, to get to people's hearts, to get to people's minds?”
Matt Borron at the Association of Defense Communities said local inclusion efforts are important, but the military’s top leaders also need to act.
“It can't just be at the local level, because installation leadership might feel that they don't necessarily have top cover, that they should probably steer clear if it's controversial,” Borron said.
He’s supporting an effort in Congress that would require the Defense Department to survey military families every other year about the racial climate in defense communities.
This story was produced by the American Homefront Project, a public media collaboration that reports on American military life and veterans.Funding comes from the Corporation for Public Broadcasting.